MSNBC has done it again. The network’s talking heads, Mehdi Hasan and Ali Velshi, seem to be competing against each other in a despicable contest to trash Israel.
Throwing loaded words like “apartheid” or “racist” state, the two charlatans have clearly decided that the world’s most burning issue is the evil Zionist regime.
Unfortunately for them, their entire argument is flawed, contradictory and biased.
In a monologue this past weekend, Hasan shamelessly laments the fact that one cannot criticize Israel as an “apartheid state” without being labeled an antisemite. He then tries to prove his point by quoting “racist” remarks made by Israeli ministers.
Many countries around the world include politicians who may be deemed unsavory & even racist. Sometimes they may even be part of a government.
But that doesn't mean an entire state and its people are a reflection of a few politicians.
Who's the real racist here @mehdirhasan? https://t.co/2Az5TeNeft
— HonestReporting (@HonestReporting) September 4, 2023
But there are several problems with this twisted line of argument:
Firstly, Hasan may have forgotten that in a democracy, the opinions of government ministers do not reflect upon an entire nation. His claim may actually reflect back upon himself as someone who makes baseless collective racist accusations against the Jewish state.
Secondly, Hasan is simply sawing off the branch he is sitting on: He shows that there is freedom of speech in Israel, as well as the freedom to criticize – even when it comes to ministers whose remarks are scrutinized daily by local media. Why? Because Israel is a democracy.
He finishes his rant by saying:
Our politicians, our elected members of congress here in the U.S., are bent on convincing us that Israel isn’t guilty of apartheid or racism against the Palestinians. And anyone who says otherwise is being antisemitic. So a word of advice for them, the next time they want to take a vote on this issue, perhaps they should listen to Israel’s own ministers first.
So a word of advice to Hasan: The next time you feel like venting your poisonous resentment against the Jewish state, do your homework first.
Related reading: Live on MSNBC: Mehdi Hasan Schooled on Israel’s Fight Against Terrorists by Ukrainian Politician
Velshi: A Journalist-Turned-Activist
A monologue on the same weekend by MSNBC’s Ali Velshi descends into similar pitfalls, aiming to convince viewers that “the US should not reward Israel’s bad behavior” because the Jewish state is not a democracy but an “apartheid state.” (See the Twitter /X thread later in this piece below for the full segment.)
Yet he justifies his claim by unintentionally describing…Israel’s vibrant democracy:
The former so-called government of national unity had included political parties from the right and the left and had the support of a tiny majority of Israeli Arabs in the Knesset. But it lost in the last elections. It wasn’t a big loss but in Israel’s incredibly fragmented political system it was enough to replace the fragile coalition government with a far right populist government which now holds some of the country’s most influential positions.
Then he too goes on to criticize some statements made by Israeli government ministers, as if it reflects upon all Israelis.
But Velshi’s blunt “apartheid” allegation is where things get really dark, as shown in this thread:
He ignores the existence of the Arab citizens of Israel, who make up some 20 percent of the country’s population and enjoy full civil rights.
He likewise ignores the fact that the PA continues to deny Palestinians their right to vote in their own democratic elections.— HonestReporting (@HonestReporting) September 4, 2023
Unfortunately, such inaccuracies – and many others in his poisonous monologue – can be easily missed by the poor viewers, who tuned in to receive accurate information but were fed dark propaganda instead.
— HonestReporting (@HonestReporting) September 4, 2023
Like Mehdi Hasan, Velshi concludes his diatribe with some arrogant activist advice. He tells the US president it would be wrong to meet Israel’s thrice-indicted Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu who tries to hang on to power and heads a country whose “bad behavior,” as the piece’s headline suggests, should not be rewarded.
Related reading: False Equivalence: MSNBC Journalist Ali Velshi Compares Israel to Communist China, Assad’s Syria & Afghanistan Under Taliban Rule
It would be wiser on Velshi’s part to check his own bad behavior, because viewers might not reward it.
Liked this article? Follow HonestReporting on Twitter, Facebook, Instagram and TikTok to see even more posts and videos debunking news bias and smears, as well as other content explaining what’s really going on in Israel and the region.
Credit: Screenshots from Twitter and MSNBC
