With your support we continue to ensure media accuracy

The Guardian: Filleting the Context

The Guardian publishes what appears at first sight to be a story of hope and encouragement from Gaza surrounding the growth of fish farms. To his credit, Peter Beaumont states that “All the farms in…

Simon Plosker
September 7, 2016
12:00 am

Reading time: 2 minutes

Join the fight for Israel’s fair coverage in the news

When you sign up for email updates from HonestReporting, you will receive

However, it wouldn’t be a Guardian story without something to blame on Israel:

The Palestinian fishing industry operates under strictly enforced restrictions. An exclusion zone policed by Israel limits the industry’s range to within six miles off Gaza’s coast. Fishermen risk being shot at, arrested and having their catch confiscated.

How about some much needed context? Restrictions on Palestinian fishing are undoubtedly causing difficulties for Palestinian fishermen. But is Israel deliberately setting out to strangle the Palestinian fishing industry in a fit of malevolence?

Of course not.

Two hyperlinks to other stories also lacking the same context are no excuse for failing to point out why Israel needs to enforce a maritime exclusion zone. The main reason is smuggling of weapons to Hamas. As recently as May 2016, the IDF reported on the arrest of a Gazan fisherman:

In a combined effort between the Israeli Navy, ISA, and the Israeli Police, forces arrested Salim Jamal Hassan Na’aman in April 2016. He was apprehended after his vessel deviated from the designated fishing zone.

Na’aman explained to his investigators that he was involved in smuggling weapons, ammunition, and materials used to manufacture rockets intended for Hamas and other terror groups in the Gaza Strip. Additionally, he conveyed information on Hamas plans to use fishermen to disguise terror activity and how fisherman support smuggling efforts between Gaza Strip and Egypt.

The Guardian could also have mentioned other attempts to exploit the fishing zone by bringing in weapons to the Gaza Strip from the sea in craft disguised as fishing boats such as in the IDF video below from 2015.

Instead, lack of context keeps the scales in front of The Guardian’s readers’ eyes where it comes to legitimate Israeli security concerns.

▶ The Iranian Regime at the UN Security Council: When the Perpetrator Plays the Victim

▶ October 7 Memorial: Cars as Evidence of Mass Murder and the Stories They Hold

Why Are Ivy League Schools Quietly Rewarding Student Anti-Israel Protest Leaders?

Media Downplay Central Israel Truck Ramming as Mere Traffic Mishap

Israel at War: The Media Battlefield – Briefing #42

Tags: fishermen, fishing, Gaza, Hamas, Lack of context, naval exclusion zone, Peter Beaumont, The Guardian

Simon Plosker

With over two decades of experience in various non-governmental organizations in the UK and Israel, Simon Plosker returned to HonestReporting in October 2022 as Editorial Director having previously been part of the organization’s management team from 2005 to 2020. Prior to his first spell at HonestReporting, Simon worked in Israel for NGO Monitor, BICOM, and served for a short period in the IDF Spokesperson’s Unit. He was Managing Editor of the Geneva-based NGO United Nations Watch for two years before moving back to the frontline defending Israel from media bias. Simon has a BSoc.Sc in International Studies and Political Science from the University of Birmingham and an MSc in History of International Relations from the London School of Economics. He immigrated to Israel in 2001 from London.

HonestReporting is a USA non-profit 501(c)(3) charitable organization as recognized by the Internal Revenue Service (IRS).

Tax ID# 06-1611859. Your generous tax-deductible donations make a real difference.