In Focus

The Holocaust Does Not Need to Be Decolonized

The push to decolonize Holocaust museums dejudaizes the Shoah.

By November 18, 2026

Key Takeaways:

  • Holocaust museums must center Jewish history, experience, and testimony.
  • Decolonizing Holocaust museums risks subordinating Jewish history to contemporary political ideologies.
  • The de-Jewification of the Shoah is a form of Erasive Jew-hate.

Pennsylvania State University hosted a lecture entitled “Do We Need to Decolonize Holocaust Museums?” on November 17. The speaker, Erica Lehrer, a professor at Concordia University, had delivered the same lecture at the University of Michigan in April. The event description acknowledges that Holocaust museums were often established by survivor communities, but then asks how decolonial theory might help them “renew and expand their social justice mandates.”

Before we continue, let’s be absolutely clear: Holocaust museums do not need to be decolonized. The suggestion is preposterous. They do not need to be reimagined through contemporary ideological frameworks and repurposed to serve the current political priorities. They exist to tell the story of the attempted extermination of the Jewish people. The survivors who helped establish these institutions wanted the world to know what had been done to them, their families, and their people. These were not abstract projects designed to advance whatever social justice cause happens to dominate contemporary discourse. They were acts of Jewish testimony. Jewish remembrance. And Jewish continuity.

And given how the world still misunderstands the Shoah, and that the Jew-hate that made it possible is rising at a terrifying rate, the idea that these institutions should to expand their mandates to remain relevant is not merely misguided. It is an insult to the very people whose experiences they were established to preserve.

The Dejudaization of the Shoah

When a colleague sent me an Instagram post advertising the event, I was shocked but not surprised. This is part of a much wider trend toward the dejudaization of the Shoah, whereby the specifically Jewish experience of the Holocaust is increasingly erased or subordinated to supposedly universal lessons. This, in turn, is part of a broader phenomenon I call Erasive Jew-hate, whereby Jewish identity, Jewish experience, and our legitimacy as a people are erased, denied, or redefined by the non-Jewish world.

This is one of the dangers of progressive politics for Jews. Our history is too often treated as valuable only when it can be put to work for somebody else’s cause. The Shoah is held up as a warning about prejudice in general, about “man’s inhumanity to man,” and then the conversation moves on before anyone has had to confront the particular hatred that made it possible. The Jewish people become incidental to the telling of our own attempted extermination, while the supposedly universal lessons are elevated above the specific history from which they are drawn.

It is entirely possible to leave a Holocaust commemoration having heard everyone agree that hatred is wrong, while learning very little about the Jewish people, why we were targeted, or what we actually experienced. That is not simply a failure of Holocaust education. It is a form of anti-Jewish erasure. When the Jewish experience is removed from the center of the Shoah, the history itself is fundamentally distorted. The Holocaust becomes something that happened to an abstract category of victims rather than an attempt to annihilate a particular people, whose history, culture, civilization, and lives were the targets of Nazi hatred.

The universal lessons of the Shoah are not wrong. Hatred is wrong. But these cannot be the primary lessons of Holocaust education. The first lesson must be about the Jewish people, the Jew-hate that led to our attempted extermination, and the destruction of Jewish life and civilization across Europe. Universal lessons must emerge from an understanding of that specific history, rather than replacing it. As journalist Michael Starr has observed, when you make something for everyone, you make it for no one.

No serious educator would teach the history of anti-Black racism in America as a general lesson about intolerance, stripped of slavery, racial ideology, and the systems that sustained them. We understand that the particular matters, that the experiences of a specific people cannot simply be repurposed to teach broader moral lessons while their own history is pushed aside. Yet this is precisely what is increasingly demanded of Jewish history. Jews are owed the same respect and understanding.

Who Gets to Tell Our Story?

This is also a question of who gets to tell the story. Erasive Jew-hate is not simply about ignoring Jewish history. It is about replacing Jewish understandings of our identity, experience, and belonging with interpretations imposed upon us by the non-Jewish world. The danger is not always that the Shoah will be forgotten. It is that the Shoah will be remembered, commemorated, and taught in ways that progressively erase the Jewish people from the center of our own history.

Jews understood the importance of telling our own story even as we were being murdered. In the Warsaw Ghetto, the historian Emanuel Ringelblum created a secret archive, Oneg Shabbat, with several dozen contributors. They gathered thousands of pages of documents, drawings, posters, and photographs, and buried them in metal boxes and milk cans. Ringelblum did not survive the war. Two of the three caches were recovered. The historian Samuel Kassow called his 2007 study of the archive Who Will Write Our History? That question was the point. Ringelblum and his colleagues knew that if they did not record Jewish life and Jewish death in their own words, someone else would tell the story for them.

This was not just an exercise in historical documentation. It was an assertion of Jewish agency in the face of an attempt to destroy not only Jewish lives but Jewish existence itself. Ringelblum and his colleagues understood that those who survived the destruction, or inherited its memory, would have to contend with the possibility that the Jewish experience would be distorted, appropriated, or forgotten. They were determined that the Jewish people would not be denied the authority to tell our own story.

Survivors carried that work forward. Yad Vashem began collecting written testimonies in the late 1940s, and its archives now hold more than 131,000. These testimonies are not simply historical sources to be fitted into whichever intellectual framework happens to dominate contemporary scholarship. They are the voices of Jews describing what happened to them, what they lost, and how they understood their experiences. Their perspectives must remain central to how the Shoah is remembered and taught.

This is where the language of decolonization becomes particularly troubling. A 2022 article in the Journal of the Canadian Historical Association asked whether the Montreal Holocaust Museum, founded by survivors, could be decolonized. Among the themes it examined was the exhibit’s treatment of Palestine and Israel, and it concluded that the exhibit reinscribes settler colonial narratives.

Someone will tell me this is simply a scholarly question. But when a museum established by Holocaust survivors is asked to reinterpret its history through a framework that casts the Jewish return to our ancestral homeland as colonialism, we must ask whose understanding of Jewish history is being privileged and whose is being displaced. Jewish indigeneity, Jewish peoplehood, and Jewish self-determination are not external political questions that can simply be separated from Jewish history. They are part of how Jews understand our own identity and continuity.

When these understandings are subordinated to ideological frameworks that deny their legitimacy, the result is not simply a different interpretation of Jewish history. It is the replacement of a Jewish account with one imposed from outside. That is erasure.

Jewish Studies and Self-Erasure

What makes the Penn State lecture particularly striking is that it was hosted by a Jewish Studies program. Yet this is not surprising. Across the world, Jewish Studies has increasingly become a space in which Jewish identity, history, and experience are interpreted, and often distorted, through intellectual frameworks developed outside the Jewish world, with little regard for how Jews understand ourselves as a people. Rather than challenging the assumptions and prejudices of the wider academic world, significant parts of the discipline have surrendered to them, absorbing and reproducing ideas that deny Jewish peoplehood, undermine Jewish indigeneity, and erase Jewish experience.

In many cases, Jewish Studies departments have become so consumed by the ideological fashions of contemporary academia, particularly postcolonial and decolonial theory, that they appear more interested in forcing Jewish history into predetermined political narratives than in understanding Jews on our own terms. Jewish perspectives are marginalized, while external interpretations of our history are elevated as supposedly more sophisticated, progressive, or academically legitimate. What makes this particularly insidious is that such erasure can be presented as scholarship, granting academic legitimacy to ideas that, in other contexts, would be recognized as deeply prejudicial.

But this is not simply a story of the non-Jewish world imposing its understanding of Jewish identity upon us. Jews themselves can internalize anti-Jewish ideas and participate in what I term self-erasure. This is one of the most damaging consequences of Jew-hate. It shapes how Jews understand themselves and, in turn, how they treat themselves and other Jews. When Jewish academics and institutions adopt frameworks that marginalize Jewish perspectives, they can become participants in the very process of erasure they should be challenging.

The implications for Holocaust education are especially serious. Institutions dedicated to the study of Jewish history must not become places where the Jewish experience of the Shoah is subordinated to ideological priorities that have little to do with understanding the attempted extermination of our people. The fact that such ideas can emerge from within Jewish Studies does not make them any less deserving of scrutiny. It makes the danger of self-erasure all the more urgent.

When the Witnesses Are Gone

As fewer survivors are here to speak for themselves, museums carry more of the responsibility for making their accounts available to people who will never meet one. According to the Claims Conference, fewer than 200,000 Jewish Holocaust survivors were alive at the start of 2026, with a median age of 87. Its 2025 report estimated that 70 percent would be gone within a decade. The generation that founded these museums is leaving us.

A visitor may have only a couple of hours in a museum. I want them to spend that time learning who the Jews of Europe were and why they were targeted. I want them to understand how a widely held set of ideas about Jews became the basis for a program of mass murder. I want them to hear Jews describe what they experienced in their own words, and to leave better able to recognize Jew-hate when they encounter it in their own lives.

The survivors who established these institutions understood something that we appear increasingly willing to forget: the Shoah was not an abstract lesson about humanity. It was the attempted extermination of the Jewish people. They wanted the world to understand what had happened to us, why it had happened, and what had been destroyed.

As the last survivors leave us, we have a responsibility to ensure that their testimony is neither diluted nor redefined to satisfy the ideological demands of the present. The dejudaization of the Shoah is not an act of progress. It is an act of Erasive Jew-hate.

The Jewish people have already endured the attempted destruction of our lives, our communities, and our civilization. We must not now allow the erasure of our experience.

Liked this article? Follow HonestReporting on Twitter, Facebook, Instagram and TikTok to see even more posts and videos debunking news bias and smears, as well as other content explaining what’s really going on in Israel and the region. Get updates direct to your phone. Join our WhatsApp and Telegram channels!

© Divuach Ne’eman R”A, 2025

Ben M. Freeman

Ben M. Freeman

Founder of the modern Jewish Pride movement, Ben M. Freeman is the author of Jewish Pride: Rebuilding a People (2021) Reclaiming our Story: The Pursuit of Jewish Pride (2022) and The Jews: An Indigenous People (2025). Educating, inspiring and empowering, his work focuses on Jewish identity and historical and contemporary Jew-hatred. A Holocaust scholar for over fifteen years, Ben came to prominence during the Corbyn Labour Jew-hate crisis in the UK and quickly became one of his generation’s leading Jewish thinkers and voices against Jew-hate.

Discover More

Get clear, reliable Israel news and tools to fight media bias.

Subscribe