When Crowdsourcing Reveals You’re an Idiot

Business Insider's chief editor and CEO, Henry Blodget tried to crowdsource an answer to the question, Why Do People Hate…

By May 31, 2012

Business Insider’s chief editor and CEO, Henry Blodget tried to crowdsource an answer to the question, Why Do People Hate Jews?

Bad move. In the context of Blodget’s column, the question gave legitimacy to anti-Semitism. And a stereotypical photo of Chassidic Jews added to the incongruity.

When the wisdom of the crowd rightly concluded this was idiocy, Blodget backtracked by tweaking the headline a few times and posting updates on the page. Demonstrating how seriously he views anti-Semtism, Blodget ditched the original photo for Natalie Portman (!?).

In the end, Blodget apologized at the top of his post. It strikes me as sincere and Blodget, I think, gets it now — though Portman still graces the top of the page. That’s ill-advised.

Anti-Semitism’s an important discussion to have, but there’s a time and a place for everything. Blodget’s intentions aside, discussing anti-Semitism at Business Insider under Portman’s smile is like discussing the Tokyo stock exchange at Yad Vashem’s web site illustrated with a stereotypical image of Godzilla.

Backstory with more links and screengrabs at The Daily Dot/Storify.

© Divuach Ne’eman R”A, 2025

Pesach Benson

Pesach Benson

A Baltimore native, Pesach was with HonestReporting from 2011 to 2020. He edited the Israel Daily News Stream and authored the e-book, Red Lines: HonestReporting’s 8 Categories of Media Bias. Before moving to Israel in 1995, he worked as a reporter for the Baltimore Jewish Times. Pesach has a B.A. in political science from the University of Maryland-Baltimore County, where he was executive editor of the campus newspaper.

Discover More

Get clear, reliable Israel news and tools to fight media bias.

Subscribe