Dutch Daily: “The Chosen People Have to be Perfect”
January 12, 2012 14:33 by ManagingTeamThis is a guest post by Yochanan Visser of Missing Peace.
Last week the Dutch Christian daily ‘Trouw’ reached a new low when it published a vicious article about prenatal care in Israel entitled: “The chosen people have to be perfect”.
The writer, Ilse van Heusden, gave birth to a healthy baby boy while temporarily living in Israel.
She succeeded in portraying the prenatal care in Israel as a government instigated ‘military operation’ aimed at the production of babies as perfect as possible.
Apart from distortions and lies the article contained many accusations and insinuations which are reminiscent of classic anti-Semitic rants.
Requests
After the publication of the article we [Missing Peace] contacted ‘Trouw’ with a request to allow the publication of an op-ed in which we could debunk the false claims and lies in Van Heusden’s article.
‘Trouw’ did not even bother to respond, nor did the editors respond to a similar request by the Dutch branch of the Likud party.
Examples
Here is a prime example of the anti-Semitic content of the article:
Van Heusden:
To be pregnant in Israel is comparable to a military operation. Countless echos and blood tests should produce the perfect baby, nothing can be left to the luck of the draw. The state demands healthy babies and a lot of them too.
This was later followed by an outrageous lie about child allowances in Israel.
Van Heusden:
What makes things even more emotionally charged is the Israeli demand to produce many children. The state promotes the birth of children by supplying, among other things, a considerable child allowance.
To support these outrageous claims, she misused a quote made by former Minister of the Interior Shlomo Benizri in 2002. At the time Benizri declared: “the fear of losing Israel’s unique character obligates us to take action so as not to become a minority in our own country.”
Of course Van Heusden knew very well that Benizri was not talking about more Jewish babies, but about the influx of illegal immigrants and foreign workers.
She then suggested that the way Israel promotes having children is comparable to Arafat’s policy of using the womb of Palestinian women as a weapon.
Child allowance
It is of course a lie that Israel ‘demands’ many or ‘perfect’ babies. The state does not interfere in the decision to have children; that is something Israelis decide for themselves.
It is also a lie that the state promotes child birth with considerable child allowances.
In fact, since 2002, the Israeli government has considerably reduced the level of child allowances. This reduction rose to as high as 70% for a family with 8 children.
An average child now receives 35 Euros ($44) per month.
That is far below the Netherlands where child allowance is an average of 120 Euro ($152) per month for children born before 1995, and roughly 75 Euro ($95) for children born since then.
Furthermore, this summer thousands of Israelis demonstrated against the fact that parents themselves had to pay for daycare of their children up till the age of five years (The Israeli government recently reduced the age to three years).
Racist state
After writing that she was diagnosed with the Cytomegalovirus (CMV) virus and as a result was requested to conduct an additional test, Van Heusden exclaimed:
I was surprised about the spasmodic attitude about this test and the previous one. After all children are loved and honored here and Israel is a paradise when it comes to having children … But the flipside of the story is that having children is a demand and a discussion about that demand is not possible.
In actual fact, the prenatal program in Israel consists of recommendations only; a woman can refuse to conduct any test at all stages of pregnancy.
Van Heusden then compared the Israeli prenatal care to the Dutch system which she holds in high esteem:
Every time I had to undergo such a test (diabetes blood test) it caused distress. In the Netherlands my first pregnancy was without problems and it was dealt with by the obstetrician accordingly. I was boring but ‘boring was good’, explained the obstetrician.
I am healthy and not in the category of the Ashkenazi Jews … yet I had to experience twelve echo tests and four blood tests”.
Writing about the birth of her son Van Heusden said:
finally we held this little baby boy in our arms that went through all those tests. When we admired his little fingers and toes we saw that one of his toes was too small. His personal revenge on the Israeli health system.
It is obvious that Van Heusden twisted everything that was done to safeguard her health and that of her child into an attempt to prove that Israel is a racist state which has a system to produce perfect babies.
Her claims are so outrageous that rebuttal seems beyond the pale.
Basic facts
However to understand the viciousness of the claims in her article it is nevertheless useful to provide some basic facts about Israeli prenatal care and the health system in general.
First of all, prenatal care in Israel is organized according to World Health Organization recommendations and is now on a higher level than that in the Netherlands.
Furthermore, Van Leusden was diagnosed with the CMV virus, which is the sole explanation for the many tests she had to undergo. In her article she admits that CMV can cause severe damage to the fetus.
Several Israeli women wrote us that on an average, 4 to 5 echo (ultrasound) tests are usual and not 12 as in the case of Van Leusden. Another woman from northern Israel claimed that her twins owed their lives to these echo tests.
Van Leusden’s criticism about the diabetes blood test is completely unjustified. This test – standard procedure in all modern medical systems – is designed to detect gestational diabetes; a disorder which can have serious and even fatal consequences for mother and child.
Mortality rate
Through this type of advanced prenatal care, Israel has managed over the last 35 years to reduce the infant mortality rate by almost 70% (24.6 per 1000 infants in 1973 compared to 3.8 per 1000 in 2008).
A similar figure was reached among the Arab population in Gaza and the West Bank (now the lowest in the entire Middle East: 11 per 1000 compared to 58 in 1968 and 61 in Iraq nowadays).
It is also the reason Israel now has a lower infant mortality rate than the Netherlands, which has one of the worst rates in Western Europe.
High quality care
The high quality of Israeli health care is in part due to prevention programs such as prenatal care. There are nationwide population examinations for breast and colon cancer. Blood tests are almost standard during visits to a doctor.
As a result people are living longer (81.6 years in Israel compared with an average of 79.5 in the OECD). Israel has one of the highest cancer survival rates in the world (84% breast cancer survival rate in 2009). The same applies to the survival rate after a stroke (CVA) and Myocardial Infarction.
All this was achieved with a health budget which is approximately 60% lower than in the Netherlands ($2,165 per person per year compared with $5144 in the Netherlands) and a number of hospital beds that is far below the OECD average (2 per 1000 compared with 3.5 in OECD countries).
Eugenics
Of course all of this data was also at Van Heusden’s disposal.
However, she chose to write a libelous article where care for an unborn child in Israel was deliberately presented as a military operation and as a political weapon born out racist motives.
When an Israeli caretaker finally had enough of her complaints about the excellent prenatal care in Israel and made a sarcastic joke about the need for ‘the chosen people to be perfect’, she used it to make her point.
One ‘Trouw’ reader summarized the article as follows:
Subtle article by the way, it even manages to bring good infant care in Israel in the vicinity of “eugenics” and thus comparing it to Nazism.
Indeed such articles can normally be found on the websites of white supremacists such as David Duke or on anti-Semitic sites such as Jew Watch.
The fact that a Dutch Christian mainstream paper published it should sound alarms in The Netherlands.
The paper should issue an apology and dissociate itself from writers like Ilse van Heusden.
Trouw’s article deserves to be exposed to a wider non-Dutch speaking audience. Here’s your chance to let Trouw know how appalling this is. Send your considered comments to Trouw’s editorial team – redactie@trouw.nl
UPDATE: Dutch Daily Deluged Over Anti-Semitic Article
Image: CC BY-SA HonestReporting.com, flickr/Bruce Berrien, flickr/juanktru.
Moked – il portale dell´ebraismo italiano » Blog Archive » Voci a confronto
1:33 pm
Jan 18, 2012
[...] esteri e quindi mi limito a segnalare un articolo pubblicato nei giorni scorsi sull’olandese Trouv. E’, in pratica, anche un consiglio a tutte le lettrici: se, in Israele per turismo o per [...]
Agree or Disagree:
0 
0
b.kline
2:13 am
Jan 19, 2012
Perhaps she would have been happier for her baby to be born during hitler’s regime where it was common practice to take the new born child and smash it’s head against a wall! – no pleasing some people!
Well-loved. Agree or Disagree:
4 
0
Dagblad Trouw vindt het verdacht dat Israëlische ouders gezonde baby’s willen
2:20 am
Jan 19, 2012
[...] Dutch Daily: “The Chosen People Have to be Perfect” (Honest Reporting). [...]
Agree or Disagree:
2 
0
Herbert Kaine
4:41 pm
Jan 19, 2012
I hope she chooses to have her next baby in Somalia. Since she is raising her children to be anti-Jewish martyrs, Somalia would be the ideal place to give birth
Well-loved. Agree or Disagree:
17 
3
chris
6:15 pm
Jan 19, 2012
She and her child recieved probably the best medical care in the world and the same considered care as any Israeli or Arab living in Israel.That says more for the eithics of Judiasm than for the Christian anti semites any day. Europe is infused with the shame of its past and has not repented. Therefore its house is left empty and morally bankrupt. I think for a reality check her next child should be born in GAZA. She will see the high regard the Palestinians have for her and her Christian child.
Well-loved. Agree or Disagree:
19 
1
Elliott Brennon
6:20 pm
Jan 19, 2012
Perhaps it’s time to for HR to encourage the publication’s readers to cancel subscriptions in a “Drop Trouw” campaign?
Well-loved. Agree or Disagree:
17 
1
BARRY G KOHAN
7:49 pm
Jan 19, 2012
The printing of this article by Tronw shows what a rag this paper is.Look for your copy at the check out counter of your local Dutch super market in the tabloid section.
Well-loved. Agree or Disagree:
7 
1
Geoff H-T
12:37 am
Jan 20, 2012
Writing as a Christian who supports Israel, I am ashamed that Trouw lets itself be referred to as a ‘Christian’ publication. On several counts it has failed to be as perfect as perhaps thjey should be, not least in terms of the courtesy of a reply to Honest Reporting.
Well-loved. Agree or Disagree:
12 
1
Update: Dutch Daily Deluged Over Anti-Semitic Article | The Conservative Papers
10:18 pm
Jan 19, 2012
[...] Christian daily Trouw’s vicious article about prenatal care in Israel entitled: “The chosen people have to be perfect”, provoked a [...]
Well-loved. Agree or Disagree:
8 
2
Carol Young
11:41 pm
Jan 19, 2012
Forget the rantings of an irrational women. I’d like to know why Trouw published this anti-semitic article that manipulated a nurturing, sophisticated medical system to be perceived as a negative attribute.
Well-loved. Agree or Disagree:
15 
0
Lynne
3:25 pm
Jan 20, 2012
It is outrageous that a periodical called “Truth” would publish an article with so many lies and distortions. (“The Chosen People Have to Be Perfect”)
When can I expect to read an apology and a corrected version?
Lynne Bright
Well-loved. Agree or Disagree:
12 
1
Disgusted
1:57 am
Jan 24, 2012
She’s COMPLAINING that she got excellent care? That’s beyond ridiculous. She’s so blatantly anti-Israel, it’s horrifying. First, she has a healthy pregnancy, and does not need extensive testing, so it must be due to the terrific care she got at home. Then she contracts a potentially serious virus, is given as much intervention as possible to assure a healthy child, and she BLAMES Israel for doing everything they could? Finally, she celebrates that her child has one toe that is too SMALL, and she calls it revenge? (Number one, that seems like such a stupid detail overall, thank heavens your baby is healthy! Two, why get your child involved in this? Three, that seems to imply the excellent service, and of course G-d’s help, that she received!) Take your spiteful little child (I mean, yourself), and leave. We’re sorry to have provided you with excellent care.
Well-loved. Agree or Disagree:
12 
0
m
5:47 pm
Jan 24, 2012
“Finally, she celebrates that her child has one toe that is too SMALL, and she calls it revenge?”
She sounds like a muslim that would rather cut her nose to spite her face. Only those ppl could possibly rejoice in their own child’s deformity just to seek “revenge”.
That is beyond sick …
Well-loved. Agree or Disagree:
8 
0
m
5:44 pm
Jan 24, 2012
WTF?! As if she was held down against her will, and subjected to batteries of tests?
The woman is a disgrace to the normally sane Dutch ppl. She is an embarrassment tot the Holland.
Well-loved. Agree or Disagree:
8 
0
Hilary
8:34 am
Jan 29, 2012
this woman was living temporarily in israel and benefited from the full care accorded to every israeli woman, and she is complaining about that? her article says more about her than about israel. strikes me she was looking for grounds to complain & criticise, and whatever happened she’d've found material for an anti-israel article. after all, there’s no pleasing some people.
Agree or Disagree:
3 
0
J.M.Jordan
11:09 am
Jan 29, 2012
I just sent Trouw a letter – hope you/Israel’ll get an apology after that?
Agree or Disagree:
3 
0
Likoed Nederland / Likud of Holland
12:32 pm
Jan 29, 2012
No chance. We dit not get it either, we mailed them twice.
Agree or Disagree:
3 
0
steve mann
1:08 pm
Jan 29, 2012
I received an email reply in Dutch- Still have not been able to translate it-
However they give that many links- I think to places to complain I gave up-
Agree or Disagree:
2 
0
Victor
1:11 pm
Jan 29, 2012
I do hope Ilse is not coming back to Israel and her passport has been stamped accordingly.
I do so hope she enjoys sex and travel.
Agree or Disagree:
0 
0
2012 Year in Review: Media Bias Report | The Conservative Papers
6:00 am
Apr 08, 2013
[...] HonestReporting partnered with Missing Peace (page 14) [...]
Agree or Disagree:
0 
0