On September 2, 2023, the streets of south Tel Aviv were turned into a warzone as rival groups of Eritrean expats battled amongst themselves and then, later, with the Israeli police, who were attempting to disperse the melee.
The riot began when Eritreans opposed to the dictatorial regime in their home country confronted a group of Eritreans celebrating the African country’s independence. The confrontation quickly turned into a full-blown rampage, with members of both the pro-government and opposition camps attacking each other with pieces of lumber, metal, rocks, and at least one axe.
Ultimately, the Israeli police were forced to use a variety of riot dispersal methods, including tear gas, stun grenades, and live ammunition fired in the air, to quell the riot and return calm to the area.
With roughly 150 people injured, the brawl garnered a significant amount of international media attention.
While most of the media accurately portrayed the riot, several news outlets disproportionately focused on the police response, creating the false impression that the tumult was essentially a dispute between Eritrean refugees and the Israeli police.
Several commentators on social media also used the police response as an opportunity to malign the Jewish state.
WATCH: Over 100 people were injured as protests in Tel Aviv by Eritrean asylum seekers against the East African nation's regime turned violent.
Read more: https://t.co/XEM8rIR7ve#Israel | #Riot | (CREDIT: Via @MaarivOnline) pic.twitter.com/DegIhJ1Fal
— The Jerusalem Post (@Jerusalem_Post) September 2, 2023
Spotlighting the Israeli Police, Downplaying the Intra-Eritrean Riot
Several international news outlets played down the violent clash between the two groups of Eritreans and instead focused heavily on the Israeli police’s response.
For example, the BBC’s initial headline reported it as “Police clash with Eritrean asylum seekers.” Even though the headline was later updated, the article continued to dedicate several paragraphs to the police response while only briefly referring to the violent confrontation between the Eritrean groups in two paragraphs.
The BBC report even went so far as to implicitly blame Israel for the rampage, claiming that it “was sparked after activists opposed to the Eritrean government said they asked Israeli authorities to cancel an embassy event on Saturday.”
A riot was sparked when rival groups of Eritrean asylum seekers fought each other on the streets of Tel Aviv.
But that doesn't fit with @BBCWorld's false framing of Israel as a racist state. So @YolandeKnell twists the narrative to turn the Israeli police into the aggressors. https://t.co/AmU8EieCbj pic.twitter.com/7kY260zKKd
— HonestReporting (@HonestReporting) September 3, 2023
Similarly, The Guardian’s report, under the headline “Eritrean asylum seekers and police injured in clashes in Israel,” dedicated the majority of its coverage to the skirmish between the police and the Eritrean rioters.
When referencing the initial clashes that pre-empted the police response, The Guardian only mentioned a “demonstration” that “turned violent” as well as “clashes…between supporters and opponents of the Eritrean regime.”
This is a far cry from its coverage of a similar riot in early August in Sweden. In that instance, nearly the entire piece was dedicated to describing the intra-communal fighting and not the police’s response.
This false portrayal of the riot as primarily a clash between the police and Eritrean refugees was also evident in Sky News’ headline, “More than 140 injured in clashes between Eritrean asylum seekers and Israeli police.”
Voice of America’s one-minute video, “Eritrean Asylum-Seekers Clash With Israeli Police,” predominantly featured images of the police response and almost no coverage of the violent skirmishes that precipitated the response.
The story was not newsworthy for The New York Times until, 24 hours later, the Israeli government began discussing a plan to deport those who had engaged in the violence, contributing to a false and misleading media narrative that portrays the Israeli police and government as the aggressors and victimizers of Eritrean refugees.
The @nytimes didn't initially cover the riot that took place between opposing factions of Eritrean asylum seekers in Tel Aviv.
That it became a story only once the Israeli PM threatened to deport Eritrean migrants speaks volumes about the New York Times.https://t.co/oo68Mv9QKW pic.twitter.com/KQ47xq7Nxc
— HonestReporting (@HonestReporting) September 4, 2023
Misrepresenting the Riot on Social Media
Some anti-Israel social media personalities took their hate to the extreme by erasing any mention of the clash between the two Eritrean groups and portraying the Israeli police as using deadly force without provocation.
The British rapper Lowkey claimed that “Israeli police opened fire with live ammunition on a protest of Eritrean refugees in Tel Aviv” while pro-Palestinian activist Heather Alexandra was more blunt in her revolting message by tweeting that “Israeli police fired live bullets at black people in Tel Aviv today.”
Israeli police opened fire with live ammunition on a protest of Eritrean refugees in Tel Aviv.
Over 100 protestors are injured, including 13 in serious condition.
Just another day in a racist state. pic.twitter.com/O0qtX5fZdu
— Lowkey (@Lowkey0nline) September 2, 2023
Independent journalist Rafael Shimunov claimed that “There are images of corpses of Eritrean refugees who were murdered by Israeli police in a playground” (even though there were no reported deaths from the riot at the time of his tweet) and that “Their ‘crime’ was protesting an event by the Eritrean embassy. Rather than deescalate…they used bullets and will now smear the dead.”
Palestinian journalist Mariam Barghouti tweeted that “Israeli police are brutally cracking down on Eritrean refugees in Tel Aviv,” adding that this signified the “essence and core of Israeli supremacy. A single ethnoreligious state for White Jewish people.”
Barghouti clearly doesn’t account for the fact that the vast majority of Israeli citizens are of non-European descent.
Various skirmishes have occurred around the world between expatriate Eritrean supporters and opponents of its government. However, only the melee that occurred in Israel seems to have resulted in a change of narrative to turn an intra-Eritrean conflict into one between the police and Eritrean expats.
Liked this article? Follow HonestReporting on Twitter, Facebook, Instagram and TikTok to see even more posts and videos debunking news bias and smears, as well as other content explaining what’s really going on in Israel and the region.
Photo Credits: Omer Fichman via Flash90
