Amnesty International on Tuesday released a report that charges Israel with maintaining a “cruel system of apartheid” since the country’s creation in 1948. The London-based NGO accused Israeli governments of striving for over seven decades to establish “Jewish domination and control over specific areas of strategic importance,” while treating Palestinians and Israeli Arabs as “inferior non-Jewish racial group[s].”
The 280-page document titled, “Israel’s Apartheid Against Palestinians. Cruel System of Domination and Crime Against Humanity,” concludes with a call to “dismantle” what Amnesty refers to as Jerusalem’s “system of oppression and domination,” and to allow millions of descendants of Palestinian refugees to “return” to Israel, a recipe for ending Jewish self-determination.
While Amnesty’s allegations generated widespread media coverage (see, for example, here, here and here), the self-proclaimed “global movement for human rights” has essentially recycled patently false claims.
When a Muslim Israeli minister needs to tell you that Israel isn’t an apartheid state, you know you have a problem.@amnesty how’s that report working out for you? #SHAMnesty https://t.co/YdIMBfouB4
— Tamar Schwarzbard (@TSchwarzbard) February 1, 2022
HonestReporting has thoroughly debunked the apartheid libel, including in a recent article titled, “‘Apartheid’ Myth: The Improper Use of False and Misleading Claims Regarding Israel,” that noted:
That apartheid refers to the policy of racial segregation in pre-1990s South Africa, a construct that does not remotely apply to Israel, is seemingly irrelevant to the UN, ostensible human rights groups and the media….
Since the signing of the Oslo Accords in the 1990s, the vast majority of Palestinians have been governed by either the Palestinian Authority in the West Bank or Hamas — which, mind you, is considered a terrorist group by most Western countries — in Gaza. The PA, specifically, was created with the support of the international community, with Palestinian leaders willingly agreeing to adopt partial autonomy while granting Israel security control in some disputed areas….
Israel is a country where Arabs serve as Supreme Court Justices, fighter pilots, Members of Kneset, artists, athletes, in fact everything that Israelis do, Arab Israelis do, as explored in depth numerous times by HonestReporting.”
Indeed, Amnesty International had to resort to formulating a totally new definition of what it calls “the crime of apartheid” in order to place Israel in the docket.
On page 37 of its report, Amnesty concedes that it “does not seek to argue that, or assess whether, any system of oppression and domination as perpetrated in Israel and the OPT [Occupied Palestinian Territories] is, for instance, the same or analogous to the system of segregation, oppression and domination as perpetrated in South Africa between 1948 and 1994.”
That the OPT designation is in and of itself biased is an irony apparently lost on Amnesty’s staff.
Instead, Amnesty manipulates reality through its reliance on bits and pieces of text from the International Convention on the Suppression and Punishment of the Crime of Apartheid. Drafted in the 1970s, only about half of the countries in the world signed on to this document. Meanwhile, modern, western liberal democracies — including the United States and the United Kingdom — did not adopt it.
Additionally, Amnesty in its report used elements of the Rome Statute, which was also adopted by about half of existing nations but, tellingly, is strongly opposed by world powers including the US.
In doing so, Amnesty constructed a new definition of apartheid that, obviously, has not been adopted by any country.
In April 2021, Human Rights Watch (HRW) employed a similar method when it accused Israel of “committing the crimes against humanity of apartheid and persecution.” HonestReporting detailed the problems associated with this Orwellian tactic.
In a video, we also explained how HRW’s and, now, Amnesty’s actions put the world’s most vulnerable populations at risk.
Amnesty further twists international law by advocating for the “return” of some 5.7 million “Palestinian refugees” to what is now Israel. In Amnesty’s distorted view, every descendant of the original 750,000-odd Palestinians who fled Israel during the 1948 war should be granted a “right of return” — a demand not supported by international law.
The actualization of this “return” would, in practice, spell the end of the Jewish state.
Moreover, following a HonestReporting petition in January 2021, outgoing US secretary of state Mike Pompeo confirmed that, in fact, less than 200,000 actual Palestinian refugees from 1948 are still alive.
HonestReporting has repeatedly proved that reports such as the latest one released by Amnesty are inherently biased (see here, here and here).
As The Wall Street Journal’s editorial board wrote, Amnesty “…treats Israel’s founding as the original sin from which all other offenses flow. In the 27-page executive summary alone, we counted at least 26 references to 1948 or 1947-1949. Amnesty’s message is that Israel was created as an apartheid state and continues as such today.”
WSJ editorial: "The Amnesty report isn’t one more denunciation of the Israeli settlements in the West Bank. . . . The report treats Israel’s founding as the original sin from which all other offenses flow."https://t.co/2AjYDUuueW
— Elliot Kaufman (@ElliotKaufman6) January 31, 2022
Not mincing words, Israel’s Foreign Ministry in a statement condemned Amnesty’s report as “intended to demonize Israel and pour fuel into the engines of antisemitism.”
US Democratic lawmaker from New York Ritchie Torres expressed a similar sentiment:
Calling Israel an apartheid state, as @amnesty has done, is a lie. The hysterical demonization of Israel will do nothing to alleviate Palestinian suffering. It will only incite hatred for the world’s largest Jewish community amid violent Antisemitism.https://t.co/3ruKu65Qmj
— Rep. Ritchie Torres (@RepRitchie) February 1, 2022
This conclusion accords perfectly with the findings of our extensive research.
Join the fight for Israel’s fair coverage in the news
Liked this article? Follow HonestReporting on Twitter, Facebook, Instagram and TikTok to see even more posts and videos debunking news bias and smears, as well as other content explaining what’s really going on in Israel and the region. Get updates direct to your phone. Join our WhatsApp and Telegram channels!
Featured Image: Mostafa Alkharouf/Anadolu Agency via Getty Images
