On Tuesday, March 7, South African lawmakers voted to downgrade the status of the South African embassy in Israel as a “gesture of solidarity” with the Palestinian people.
The National Freedom Party (NFP), which has just two seats in the country’s parliament, proposed the resolution and allied itself with the ruling African National Congress Party (ANC) to push it through.
And while the resolution was approved, it proved contentious, with only 52 percent voting in favor.
Announcing the result which merely formalizes a decision taken four years ago to give the embassy the status of liaison office, Ahmed Shaik Emam, the leader of the NFP, described the Jewish state as built on a foundation of “murder”:
This resolution demands accountability from Israel. The State of Israel was built through the displacement, murder, and maiming of Palestinians… This institution of apartheid by the State of Israel contravenes international law and is a violation of the human rights of Palestinians.”
In an earlier press release, Emam claimed that the late human rights icon Nelson Mandela would have “been proud of this decision” — a ludicrous suggestion considering Mandela’s memoir “Long Walk to Freedom” contained numerous positive comments about Israel.
Africa4Palestine, a pro-BDS campaign group with over 64k followers on Twitter, also welcomed the decision:
South African Parliament adopts historic motion to downgrade Israel embassy
Africa4Palestine welcomes today’s motion adopted with an overwhelming majority by SA Parliament to support the downgrade of Israel Embassy
208 for/94 against
Salute NFP!https://t.co/GdBkHgnnY6 pic.twitter.com/DtM2k115Dz
— #Africa4Palestine (@Africa4Pal) March 7, 2023
However, it would appear that the resolution did not have the desired effect for those who wish to demonize and ostracize the world’s only Jewish state.
Rather than prompt a flurry of media activity by outlets both reporting the decision and speculating on whether other countries could soon follow suit, the move appeared to amount to a damp squib (anticlimactic event) as far as international (and domestic) interest is concerned.
Instead, it came across as a failed PR stunt by hypocritical politicians in South Africa who would prefer grinding their anti-Israel axes than addressing more pressing concerns.
Criticizing the resolution, the South African Zionist Federation (SAZF) noted that while the ANC government “obsesses over Israel, it is also hosting navy drills with Russia, which is responsible for terrible war crimes and the deaths of thousands of innocent Ukrainian civilians over the past year.”
Rowan Polovin, national chairman of the SAZF, also commented on how little coverage in South Africa the decision generated:
There has been surprisingly little local coverage of the issue in the print and digital media. A handful of articles which mostly published parts of our statement. Some radio and TV coverage, a bit of hostility but nothing too dramatic.”
Additionally, a spokesperson for the South African Jewish Board of Deputies pointed out that where the issue has received some media coverage, the reportage has been based on press releases giving both sides of the argument.
South Africa’s confirmation of its 2019 move to downgrade diplomatic ties with Israel is disappointing.
However, it is heartening to see how little impact it is having in the international arena.
Liked this article? Follow HonestReporting on Twitter, Facebook, Instagram and TikTok to see even more posts and videos debunking news bias and smears, as well as other content explaining what’s really going on in Israel and the region.
