Following criticism of a lecture hosted by Pennsylvania State University Jewish Studies Department titled “Do We Need to Decolonize Holocaust Museums?”, Penn State University issued a statement on November 18, distancing itself from the views of external speakers and acknowledging concerns about the use of the term “decolonization.”
The statement included an explanation from Tommaso M. Milani, director of the university’s Jewish Studies Program, who argued that decolonization in the context of museums concerns ethical questions surrounding collections, representation, and historical injustices. According to Milani, the lecture specifically examined the treatment of objects taken from Jewish individuals and communities, including those never returned to survivors or their descendants.
He also insisted that neither the lecture nor the subsequent discussion diminished the significance of the Holocaust, the experiences of survivors, or the importance of Holocaust museums.
There is an enormous difference between examining the provenance of stolen Jewish property and proposing that Holocaust museums should expand their social justice mandates. The former is an entirely legitimate and necessary undertaking. The latter raises fundamental questions about the purpose of Holocaust museums and whose interests they are supposed to serve.
Indeed, the original advertisement explicitly stated that decolonial theory could help Holocaust museums “renew and expand their social justice mandates.” There was no reference to restitution. The description situated Holocaust museums within a broader movement to decolonize museums, raising questions about institutional power, inherited biases, exclusions, and silences.
How does the subsequent explanation account for this language? What exactly does expanding the social justice mandates of Holocaust museums mean? And why is this supposedly necessary?
There is also the question of why Penn State’s Jewish Studies Program chose to advertise a lecture about Holocaust museums in the language of decolonization. Whatever the term means within museum studies, the lecture was open to the public and the advertisement did not explain how the term was being used. In wider political discourse, that language is routinely used to cast Jews as colonizers and deny our historical connection to Israel. In that context, it should have been obvious why many Jews would find its application to Holocaust museums offensive. Either the program’s leadership failed to see that or they saw it and did not care. Both are equally concerning.
These questions go to the heart of the argument I made originally. The danger of de-Jewifying the Shoah is that the Holocaust will continue to be taught and commemorated even as the Jewish story at its center is erased. In its place, we are offered a version of the Holocaust in which the attempted extermination of our people serves as a lesson about whatever political cause one wants to advance today.
Penn State’s statement does not adequately address this concern. Instead, it offers a much narrower explanation of the lecture than the one originally advertised. We are now being told that the discussion concerned the ethical treatment of Jewish cultural property, when the original description explicitly proposed applying decolonial theory to expand the mandates of Holocaust museums.
If that was genuinely the objective, Penn State should explain what such an expansion would involve. If it was not, the university should explain why the lecture was advertised in those terms.
In my original article, I asked what happens to the Jewish story of the Shoah when Holocaust museums are asked to serve a broader social justice agenda. Penn State’s response leaves that question unanswered.
Read the original article here.
Liked this article? Follow HonestReporting on Twitter, Facebook, Instagram and TikTok to see even more posts and videos debunking news bias and smears, as well as other content explaining what’s really going on in Israel and the region. Get updates direct to your phone. Join our WhatsApp and Telegram channels!
© Divuach Ne’eman R”A, 2025