Some of the photographs Israel used with Amazon’s facial-recognition software came from the families themselves. In the days after October 7, while parents were still trying to find out what had happened to their children, Israeli volunteers gathered photographs and video from Telegram, TikTok and other sites. They used Amazon’s Rekognition software to compare the faces in that footage with pictures supplied by relatives and Israeli officials. By October 20, 2023, the project’s organizers told Forbes they had identified about 60 missing people in the imagery. Nobody had been rescued as a result. The volunteers handed the work over to the IDF.
I came to that account by following a link in The Guardian’s own investigation. You wouldn’t know about those families from the newspaper’s Instagram post. There was room in its six-paragraph caption to tell readers that Jeff Bezos is a billionaire. Apparently there wasn’t room to say what Israeli families had needed from his company.
The Guardian’s new disclosure concerns a different collection of photographs. According to documents obtained by the paper, an Israeli military department uploaded 3.5 million images to Amazon’s cloud in early 2024 for a facial-recognition project. Haaretz picked up the report and attributed it to The Guardian. Neither the number of photographs nor the earlier search for the missing tells us what happened to any particular Palestinian whose image was in that collection. The Guardian says it could not establish whether those photographs were taken at military checkpoints in Gaza.
There are serious questions here. Military sources told The Guardian that soldiers used facial recognition at checkpoints. A Palestinian civilian pulled aside because a computer had flagged his face would have good reason to ask what other evidence the soldiers had before detaining him. I’d want an answer to that, too. He’d be entitled to exactly the same answer if the software had been developed in Tel Aviv and the photographs had never left an army server.
What I find harder to understand is why Amazon’s involvement should itself be regarded as suspect. The Pentagon publicly named Amazon Web Services as one of four companies supplying its military cloud program. That contract tells us nothing about how an Israeli soldier used a photograph in Gaza. It does tell us that buying computing capacity from Amazon is a fairly unremarkable thing for an allied military to do. If Israel used it improperly, the question is what Israel did with it. The logo gets us no closer to an answer.
The Guardian’s reporters, Yuval Abraham and Harry Davies, also worked on NAZA, the Guardian-produced documentary about Israeli surveillance and the war in Gaza. Abraham co-directed it; Davies was one of its producers. The newspaper discloses both connections and invites readers to watch the film. I’d encourage those readers to follow the Forbes link as well. It gives them an Israeli account they can weigh for themselves, from people who actually used the software and explained why.
For a family looking through footage from October 7, the question was whether the person in the frame was someone they loved. For a Palestinian stopped at a checkpoint, it might be whether a soldier had the wrong man. Both have an interest in getting the identification right. A newspaper investigating the technology ought to be interested in both. The Guardian had both stories in hand. When it came to telling its Instagram audience why Israel used Amazon, only one of them survived the edit.
Liked this article? Follow HonestReporting on Twitter, Facebook, Instagram and TikTok to see even more posts and videos debunking news bias and smears, as well as other content explaining what’s really going on in Israel and the region. Get updates direct to your phone. Join our WhatsApp and Telegram channels!
© Divuach Ne’eman R”A, 2025