What On Earth Happened to Israel?

June 26, 2008 14:39 by

GoogleearthAndre Oboler slams the Google Earth community’s treatment of Israel:

The gap between reality and virtual reality is further exploited by political activists promoting what we term “replacement geography,” a means of controlling the virtual representation of land in place of controlling the land itself. In an information age, control on the common map may be worth more in negotiations than control on the ground . . . .

The inclusion of virtual Palestine, superimposed on Israel in the core layer of Google Earth, is an example of replacement geography advanced by technology. Those wishing to find directions, explore the cities of Israel, or randomly wander across this small piece of land are immediately taken to a politically motivated narrative unrelated to their quest. This is the sort of replacement the ancient Romans tried and failed to achieve.

User-generated content has so much to offer. It’s a shame some activists put a stain on efforts like Google Earth (or, for that matter, Wikipedia).

Category: Backspin
More in Backspin (2543 of 6183 articles)


Qassam lands in open area near Negev industrial zone this afternoon. No reported casualties. Hamas refuses to police the truce. ...