“Journalists have a responsibility to report facts without bias.”
Ironically, this quote appeared in a slanted Washington Post opinion piece containing numerous falsehoods. Written by two American-Palestinian activists, “How Media Coverage Whitewashes Israeli State Violence Against Palestinians” argues that, by “neglecting to contextualize Israeli state violence, the media has given the Israeli government a free pass, enabling it to continue ethnically cleansing the Palestinian people with impunity.”
In their April 28 article, Laura Albast and Cat Knarr furthermore assert that “headlines in outlets such as the Associated Press, the New York Times, the Guardian, the Wall Street Journal, NBC News and others use language that fails to recognize the power imbalance between the Israeli military apparatus and the native Palestinian people.”
As HonestReporting has repeatedly detailed (see, for instance, here, here, here and here), the opposite is true. In actuality, news organizations all too often dismiss the reality of Palestinian terrorism.
Case in point: on April 30, the Reuters wire service headlined an article “Israeli and Palestinian killed in West Bank violence,” lumping Israeli terror victim Vyacheslav Golev together with a former Palestinian security prisoner who was shot during violent clashes and was hailed a “martyr” by multiple US-designated terror groups (see here, here, here and here). Yihya Adwan reportedly served as a commander in the Al-Aqsa Martyrs Brigades.
Nonetheless, Albast, a senior editor at the Institute for Palestine Studies-USA, and Knarr, who serves as the US Campaign for Palestinian Rights’ communications director, accuse journalists of “conveying incomplete narratives that give reign to Israeli aggression.” In an attempt to substantiate this claim, the authors charge Israeli police with “attack[ing] Palestinian worshipers at the holy site of Al-Aqsa mosque in Jerusalem” on April 15, in what they describe as “carefully calculated… state violence.”
Authors of opinion pieces and editorials are entitled to express their personal opinions and beliefs. However, in the words of the famous Senator, the late Daniel Patrick Moynihan, “Everyone is entitled to his own opinion, but not his own facts.”
Join the fight for Israel’s fair coverage in the news
The April 15 Temple Mount Clashes
“When looking at the footage of what happened, the dynamic is obvious: forces with gear and guns versus worshipers kneeling in prayer,” Albast and Knarr declare in one of the first paragraphs, rejecting the notion that “clashes” took place between two sides. To back up their thesis, they link to Qatar-funded Al Jazeera, AlAraby’s English-language website and the Hamas-affiliated Quds News Network.
Paradoxically, in blaming Israel for the escalation, the pro-Palestinian campaigners actually echo the prevailing media narrative promoted by outlets like CNN. Yet videos posted to Palestinian social media channels tell an entirely different story.
On April 15, supporters of the Hamas terror organization launched a premeditated assault against Israeli security forces atop the Temple Mount, Judaism’s holiest site, which is also home to the Al-Aqsa Mosque. At dawn, before morning prayers, hundreds of rioters gathered at the complex for a pro-Hamas demonstration.
Video footage shows them chanting violent antisemitic slogans, including “In spirit and blood we redeemed Al-Aqsa.”
Early this morning they arrived at the Temple Mount chanting, "In the blood we redeemed al-Aqsa."
Hamas flags are seen in the background.
Using the cover of a holy weekend to incite unrest and draw Israel into a conflict.#Ramadan #Passover #Easter pic.twitter.com/YVm6WZvOVF
— Aviva Klompas (@AvivaKlompas) April 15, 2022
Meanwhile, the Palestinians collected rocks, fireworks and other projectiles inside the mosque — to be used to attack security forces. In telling police footage released that day, an officer can be heard pleading to worshippers: “I’m asking all of you to leave so we can promptly allow you back to the noon prayer. We are now cleaning the mosque compound for your safety.”
Related Video: The Real ‘Status Quo’: Unrelenting Palestinian Terrorism Desecrates Jerusalem Holy Sites
False Moral Equivalences
Albast and Knarr write that “media descriptions regularly imply a false symmetry between occupier and occupied, propping up anti-Palestinian and Islamophobic narratives that blame the Palestinian people for Israeli aggression,” decrying a perceived double standard between coverage of the Russia-Ukraine war and the Arab-Israeli conflict.
As HonestReporting has pointed out, moral equivalences between the plight of the Ukrainian people under attack by Russia and Palestinians attacking Israelis are not grounded in facts.
Palestinian terror groups do not discriminate between soldiers, civilians, men, women, children or babies, with Gaza-based Hamas referring to all citizens of the Jewish state as “Zionist soldiers,” all the while encouraging their members to carry out unprovoked attacks on Israelis.
By contrast, Ukrainians are taking up arms to fight off a military invasion that — according to most members of the United Nations Security Council and the General Assembly — violates Article 2(4) of the UN Charter.
Related Video: Reality Check, AP: Palestinian Terrorists Don’t Do ‘the Same Thing’ as Ukrainians Resisting Russian Invasion
Freedom of Worship for All
The Washington Post piece also falsely contends that Jerusalem blocked “Palestinian Christians from entering the Church of the Holy Sepulchre.” This is, of course, not true in the least. Since Israel gained control over eastern Jerusalem in a defensive war in 1967, the Jewish state has guaranteed freedom of worship for all religious groups in its capital.
Recent Israeli restrictions on the number of worshippers that can enter the church — put into place out of fear of a repeat of last year’s stampede at a Jewish holy site — are applied equally to Palestinians and foreign pilgrims alike.
Following the April 23 Holy Fire ceremony, a police spokesman emphasized that the participants “included Christians from Israel and around the world — Arabs and tourists took part in it…without regards to language, gender or nationality.”
Church of the Holy Sepulchre in Jerusalem today; thousands in attendance at the Holy Fire ceremony pic.twitter.com/MoHyT27Sqd
— Israel Foreign Ministry (@IsraelMFA) April 23, 2022
In their final attempt to smear the Jewish state, Albast and Knarr recycle the long-debunked canard that accuses Israel of practicing “apartheid.” HonestReporting has dissected this libel in several in-depth analyses (see here, here and here).
Although the blind hatred of the authors for the Jewish state comes to little surprise — after reading an an “amazing book written by a Jewish author,” Albast once ‘joked’: “I should stop googling authors’ biographies” — the Washington Post should know better than to publish outright disinformation.
Please take action by reaching out to Washington Post to — politely but firmly — demand that the opinion section stop promoting ‘alternative facts.’
Liked this article? Follow HonestReporting on Twitter, Facebook, Instagram and TikTok to see even more posts and videos debunking news bias and smears, as well as other content explaining what’s really going on in Israel and the region. Get updates direct to your phone. Join our WhatsApp and Telegram channels!
Featured Image: Shalev Shalom/TPS
